Nope, Idaho’s Not a ‘Scroll-Down State.’ Lots of Positive Stats Refute the Negative Spin!

Aug. 8, 2018

Most of us know Idaho is a great place to live, work and raise a family. We have a thriving economy, a jobs climate that is improving by leaps and bounds, an education system that is benefiting from ongoing new investments and reforms, family-friendly values, and a strong devotion to our Constitutional rights.

You may not get that impression from reading some of the news coverage that focuses largely on the negative, or from the Down-on-Idaho Democrats in the state Legislature and elsewhere who call Idaho a “scroll-down state” and cherry-pick statistics to try to make Idaho look bad, but a lot of great things are happening here!

Under Republican leadership, our state is doing very well — and here we’ll share some of the positive rankings and statistics about Idaho:

Idaho Leads the Nation in Employment Gains

Brand-new numbers from the U.S. Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics show Idaho leads the nation, along with Utah, for yearly employment gains.

From 2017 to 2018, Idaho saw a 3.0 percent increase in total nonfarm employment. According to the BLS, 21,700 jobs were added in Idaho over the year.


Idaho Leads the Nation in Household Income, Earnings Growth

Idaho is first in the nation for growth in median household income, according to the most recent (published Sept. 2017) numbers from the U.S. Census Bureau.

The U.S. Commerce Department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis released numbers in March that showed Idaho leading the nation in earnings growth, and second in the nation in personal income growth.


Three Idaho Cities Rank in Top 100 Job Markets

In June the career website Zippia published its analysis of 2018’s best job markets . Pocatello, Idaho Falls and Boise all ranked in the top 100.

Pocatello is 28th, Idaho Falls 52nd and Boise 97th. You can read our news release here.


Idaho First in the Nation for Teacher Pay Increases, and is NOT Last in the Nation for Teacher Pay

Given how much Idaho taxpayers have invested in boosting teacher pay over the past several years, we were surprised when we saw a recent headline touting a national report that said Idaho teachers are the lowest-paid in the nation (it’s a statistic that has since been repeated by some Democratic candidates).

As it turns out, the report is based on significantly out-of-date numbers, as noted here by State Board of Education President Linda Clark. The report covered four years ending in 2015, which was the very year Idaho began implementing its “Career Ladder” teacher salary increases.

The April 2018 edition of the National Education Association’s yearly Ranking of the States (covering the year 2017) shows Idaho improving in salaries of both teachers and instructional staff. For 2016-17, Idaho ranked 17th highest for year-to-year increases in instructional staff salaries, and 8th highest for increases in teacher salaries.

But where Idaho really stands out is in the NEA’s 2018 Estimates: For 2017-18, Idaho is first in the nation, by far, for percentage increases in both teacher and instructional staff salaries!

Here is some context for these numbers:

  • Idaho’s 2017-18 increase of 3.6 percent in average teacher salary is far above the 1.4 percent national average; the next highest state is Montana with a 2.6 percent increase.
  • Idaho’s 2017-18 increase of 3.6 percent in average instructional staff salary likewise dwarfs the 1.5 percent national average.


Idaho Education Reality Check

Democrats and other commentators are fond of selectively touting bad statistics about education in Idaho. To counteract that negative narrative, here are some other stats that paint a more balanced picture. The set of four bullet points below is from the National Association of State Budget Officers annual report on state expenditures — the most recent one was published in September 2017:

  • Idaho is tied for 6th in the nation (with Utah) for highest year-to-year increase in state funding for K-12 schools.
  • Idaho ranks 16th in the nation for total budget funding (including federal dollars) for K-12 education.
  • Idaho is 2nd in the nation for highest year-to-year increase in state funding for higher education.
  • Idaho is tied for 26th in the nation (with Montana) for total (including federal dollars) budget funding for higher education.


  • US News & World Report, partnering with McKinsey & Co, ranked Idaho 30th for education. That’s a far cry from the “last in the nation” Education Week ranking Democrats and others are always touting.
  • Regarding the Education Week rankings, which consistently put Idaho near the bottom, only one-third of its total score is based on actual student performance. In fact, on Student Achievement Idaho ranks 31st.
  • In May, – a leading national Computer Science education advocacy group – singled out Idaho and 20 other states for expanding computer science education. “Idaho,” it wrote, “has renewed $2 million of funding for CS and will require every high school to teach CS by 2020.”


Idaho 5th in the Nation for College-Ready Students

In July, U.S. News & World Report, which partners with McKinsey & Company on its research, ranked Idaho 5th in the nation for college-ready students. You can read the story here. A link to the page for Idaho is here.


Idaho Tied for 11th-Best State for Business

CNBC published its list of top states for business on July 10, and Idaho tied for 11th. In its profile of Idaho, CNBC said “The Gem State is attracting jobs with a booming manufacturing sector. But it needs to invest in education.” Which is exactly what Idaho has been doing: For four years in row, we have added more than $100 million per year in new funding for our schools. And we are heavily focusing on career & technical education.


Idaho Ranks High for Fiscal Responsibility

Pew Research regularly analyzes states’ fiscal health in its “Fiscal 50” assessments. Pew’s most recent analysis shows Idaho performing very well:


Idaho Has 8th Lowest Poverty Rate & 8th Lowest Income Inequality Rate

The Democratic candidate for governor, Paulette Jordan, caught our attention recently when she told a group of Democratic Party activists in Twin Falls that Idaho has “the worst income inequality in the country.” It didn’t sound right, so we checked. In fact, Idaho is tied for eighth-lowest income inequality in the U.S., according to the Census Bureau.

Additionally, Census Bureau numbers show that, using the Supplemental Poverty Measure as an indicator, Idaho has the eighth-lowest poverty rate in the nation.


Idaho 2nd in the Nation for Healthcare Openness & Access

In June the Mercatus Center at George Mason University issued new rankings for its Health Care Openness and Access Project. Idaho is ranked 2nd in the nation!

Mercatus’ index “measures how open and accessible each state’s healthcare system is to patient and provider preferences.” You can read more about Idaho’s ranking here.


Idaho Ranks 8th in Gallup/Sharecare’s Wellbeing of the States Index

This ranking came out several months ago, but we happened upon it only recently when we heard Democratic gubernatorial candidate Paulette Jordan tell Twin Falls County Democrats last weekend that Idaho is “50th in the nation on almost every single function of our government and our society.” As you can see for yourself, this is far from the truth.

You can read our blog post on it here.


Idaho 3rd Best State for Retirement

The website Bankrate two weeks ago published its rankings of the best and worst states for retirement. Idaho is ranked Number 3! You can read the story here.


Idaho Has Lowest Construction Unemployment Rate in the Nation

The Associated Builders and Contractors reports that in the month of June, Idaho had the lowest unemployment rate for construction jobs in the nation, at 1.7 percent:

“Idaho had the lowest rate in June, up from the 12th lowest rate in May (tied with Colorado and Oregon). It was the state’s lowest June rate since the 1.1 percent rate in June 2007.”